Updated: 3 October 2026
No goat breed is best everywhere. Each breed below was shaped by one region and one way of feeding, so the right choice depends on where the farm is and whether goats will graze or stay in a shed. As a rule: Sirohi, Marwari and Jakhrana suit dry western India, Barbari, Beetal and Totapari suit stall-feeding in the north, Black Bengal suits the humid east, Malabari suits Kerala, and Osmanabadi and Sangamneri suit Maharashtra.
The figures come from four kinds of source, marked in each cell. F is the FAO breed survey (Acharya, 1982, data from the 1970s). C is the ICAR-CIRG Annual Report 2024 (2024-25 data from research farms and field units). T and J are papers in ICAR journals. Old farmer-flock and newer research-farm figures differ, so both are shown.
Breed chart
| Breed | Home tract | Adult kg (male / female) | Kids per birth | Milk per lactation | Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sirohi | Rajasthan, Gujarat | 50 / 23 (F) | 91.5% single, 8.5% twins (F); litter 1.18 in field (C) | 71 kg (F); 86 L in field (C) | Meat |
| Jamunapari | Uttar Pradesh | 45 / 38 (F) | 69% single, 28% twins, 3% triplets (F); litter 1.25 (C) | 202 kg (F); 133 L (C) | Milk and meat |
| Beetal | Punjab | 59 / 35 (F) | 41% single, 53% twins, 7% triplets (F); litter 1.55 in field (C) | 177 kg (F); 110 kg in 90 days (C) | Milk and meat |
| Barbari | Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan | 38 / 23 (F) | Farmers: 23% single, 64% twins, 13% triplets (F); litter 1.53 (C) | 107 kg (F); 139 L (C) | Meat and milk, stall-fed |
| Black Bengal | West Bengal | 32 (4 animals only) / 20 (F) | 45% single, 51% twins, 4% triplets (F); litter 1.84 at Kalyani (C) | 58 kg (F) | Meat, skin |
| Osmanabadi | Maharashtra | 34 / 32 (F) | Farmers: 50% single, 40% twins, 10% triplets (F); litter 1.62 (C) | 0.5 to 1.5 kg a day for 3 to 5 months (F); 110 kg in 90 days (C) | Meat |
| Jakhrana | Rajasthan | 58 / 44 (F) | 57% single, 41% twins, 2% triplets (F); litter 1.3 to 1.5 in home tract (J) | 3.2 kg a day (F); 153 kg semi-intensive, 107 kg extensive (J) | Milk |
| Malabari | Kerala | 39 / 31 (F) | 51% single, 42% twins, 7% triplets (F); kidding rate 1.68 (C) | 44 kg (F); 86 L in 87 days (C) | Meat, some milk |
| Marwari | Rajasthan | 33 / 26 (F) | Mostly single (F); kidding rate 1.05 (C) | 91 kg (F); 88 L (C) | Meat, hair |
| Sangamneri | Maharashtra | 38 / 29 (F) | Farmers: 75% single, 22% twins, 3% triplets (F); 1.78 kids per kidding (C) | 83 kg (F); 120 L in 90 days (C) | Meat and milk |
| Totapari (NBAGR spelling: Totapuri) | Rajasthan | 89 / 65 at 18 months and above (T) | Litter 1.98 (T) | About 1 kg a day for 283 days (T) | Meat and milk, stall-fed |
| Boer cross | Not an Indian breed; not on the NBAGR list | No Indian figures available | No Indian figures available | No Indian figures available | Meat |
- Home tract is from the ICAR-NBAGR register. Kids per birth are in per cent. Litter is kids per kidding. Milk is per lactation, in kg or litres as printed in the source.
- Black Bengal 12-month weights in CIRG units were only 11 to 14 kg, so a Black Bengal is sold by head count, not by weight. Sirohi, Barbari and Beetal reached 22 to 31 kg at 12 months in CIRG units (C).
- The Totapari weights come from a survey of 176 keepers in Alwar and Bharatpur. They are far above the other breeds in this table, so treat them as the upper end.
Which breed for which region
- Punjab, Haryana, Delhi, western Uttar Pradesh: Beetal and Barbari. FAO describes Beetal as more prolific than Jamunapari and easier to keep in a shed.
- Rajasthan and Gujarat: Sirohi for meat, Marwari in the dry Marwar belt (33 cm rain a year, F), Jakhrana where milk is wanted, Totapari near Alwar.
- Maharashtra: Osmanabadi in the drier districts, Sangamneri around Ahmednagar, Nashik and Pune. ICAR field units record both in farmers' flocks.
- Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Odisha: Black Bengal. CIRG runs Black Bengal field units in East Champaran, Araria, Jamui and Katihar in Bihar, in Ranchi, Deoghar and other Jharkhand centres, and in West Bengal.
- Kerala: Malabari, from a home tract with about 337 cm of rain (F).
- Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, milk: Jamunapari. In a 2016 survey of 240 farmers in Firozabad and Mainpuri only 2.59% of goats were Jamunapari, while 72.4% of farmers preferred a Sirohi buck.
Stall-fed or grazing
- Stall-fed: FAO calls Barbari a dwarf breed highly suited to restrained and stall-feeding. At CIRG, Barbari kids on a six-month feedlot ration reached 27.6 kg (male) and 21.5 kg (female) at 11 months, against 20.3 and 18.2 kg on semi-intensive feeding (C). Jamunapari is more sensitive to confinement (F). The NLM guidelines list promotion of the stall-feeding model as an objective.
- Grazing or semi-intensive: Sirohi, Marwari and Jakhrana. In the Jakhrana home-tract study, goats kept semi-intensively gave 153 kg of milk against 107 kg under extensive management, and kidded every 288 days against 333 (J).
Boer cross
- Boer is not on the NBAGR register of Indian breeds. It appears in the NLM list of goat germplasm farms at the Dhoni centre in Kerala.
- An ICAR-journal trial that fed 100, 150 and 200 g of concentrate a day found Boer crossbred kids significantly heavier than local kids, with better net return per animal. Indian adult weights, kidding and mortality figures for Boer crosses are not available, so none are given here.
- Choose a Boer cross only with a vet nearby, a feed budget and a buyer who pays for weight.
Next steps
- See a flock of the breed in your district before buying. Ask the seller for birth type, weights and vaccination dates.
- Costs of a unit are in goat farm project cost. Loans and subsidy are in goat farming loan and subsidy. Housing, feed and the health calendar are in the goat farming guide, and the overview is on goat farming.
Sources
- ICAR-NBAGR, registered goat breeds with home tract
- FAO Animal Production and Health Paper 30, Sheep and goat breeds of India (Acharya, 1982), north-west chapter
- FAO Paper 30, southern peninsular chapter (Sangamneri, Malabari, Osmanabadi)
- FAO Paper 30, eastern chapter (Bengal goat)
- ICAR-CIRG Makhdoom, Annual Report 2024, goat unit reports
- Journal of Livestock Biodiversity, Totapari goats in their native habitat
- Indian Journal of Animal Sciences, production performance of Jakhrana goats in its home tract (2005)
- Indian Journal of Animal Sciences, goat production survey in Firozabad and Mainpuri (2016)
- Indian Journal of Animal Sciences, local goats and their crosses with Boer
- DAHD, National Livestock Mission operational guidelines, January 2025