Key differences
- The Eicher 557 4WD Prima G3 has 300 kg more lifting capacity than the Mahindra 585 DI - useful for heavy implements like a reversible plough, a loaded trailer or a potato planter.
- At ex-showroom prices the Mahindra 585 DI starts about ₹57,000 lower than the Eicher 557 4WD Prima G3, roughly ₹1,040 a month less on a 5-year loan for 90% at 8%.
- Drive: the Eicher 557 4WD Prima G3 is 4WD, the Mahindra 585 DI is 2WD. 4WD helps in wet paddy fields and on slopes; 2WD is cheaper to buy and maintain.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Eicher 557 4WD Prima G3 | Mahindra 585 DI |
|---|---|---|
| HP | 50 | 50 |
| Ex-showroom price | ₹7.97-8.33 lakh | ₹7.4-7.95 lakh |
| EMI (90% loan, 8%, 5 yr) | ₹14,544/month | ₹13,504/month |
| Engine capacity (cc) | 3,300 | not published |
| Cylinders | 3 | 4 |
| Rated RPM | not published | 2,100 |
| PTO HP | not published | 44.9 |
| Lifting capacity (kg) | 2,100 | 1,800 |
| Gears | 8 F + 2 R | 8 F + 2 R |
| Drive | 4WD | 2WD |
| Clutch | Dual | Dual |
| Brakes | Multi disc oil immersed | Oil immersed (OIB) |
| Steering | Power | Dual acting power steering / manual (optional) |
| Fuel tank (litres) | 65 | not published |
| Weight (kg) | 2,764 | not published |
| Wheelbase (mm) | 2,020 | not published |
| Warranty | not published | 6 years |
Specs from each maker's spec page / official spec page (closest listed variant). Prices are indicative ex-showroom; on-road price adds registration, insurance and dealer charges and varies by state.
Which one should you buy?
Match the tractor to your heaviest regular job. If you run a reversible plough, a loaded trolley or a potato planter, lifting capacity matters most. If most of your work is rotavator, thresher or pump, compare PTO HP. Then get on-road quotes for both from dealers near you, and check how far the nearest authorised service centre is - for a 10-year machine, service distance matters as much as a few HP.